Senior Men (NOBs) (1965, 1971, 2007)

50% wins 6 played, 3 wins, 2 losses, 1 draw

Grade	Round Rd	Date	Home	Away	Score
2007
C	Round 1111	Jul 7	Old CareyOld Carey	NOBSPCNOBS	92 – 37 92 – 37	L
C	Round 11	Apr 21	NOBSPCNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	103 – 135 103 – 135	L
1971
B	Round 1212	Jul 10	Old CareyOld Carey	North Old BoysNOBS	70 – 70 70 – 70	D
B	Round 44	May 8	North Old BoysNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	145 – 112 145 – 112	W
1965
D	Round 1010	Jul 3	North Old BoysNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	100 – 85 100 – 85	W
D	Round 22	May 1	Old CareyOld Carey	North Old BoysNOBS	67 – 113 67 – 113	W

Reserves Men (NOBs) (1965, 1971, 2007)

67% wins 6 played, 4 wins, 2 losses

Grade	Round Rd	Date	Home	Away	Score
2007
C	Round 1111	Jul 7	Old CareyOld Carey	NOBSPCNOBS	112 – 24 112 – 24	L
C	Round 11	Apr 21	NOBSPCNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	37 – 106 37 – 106	L
1971
B	Round 1212	Jul 10	Old CareyOld Carey	North Old BoysNOBS	32 – 62 32 – 62	W
B	Round 44	May 8	North Old BoysNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	108 – 44 108 – 44	W
1965
D	Round 1010	Jul 3	North Old BoysNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	58 – 37 58 – 37	W
D	Round 22	May 1	Old CareyOld Carey	North Old BoysNOBS	36 – 71 36 – 71	W

Senior Women (Renegades) (2024)

0% wins 1 played, 0 wins, 1 loss

Grade	Round Rd	Date	Home	Away	Score
2024
	Round 55	May 11	Brunswick RenegadesRenegades	Old CareyOld Carey	23 – 26 23 – 26	L

Club XVIII (2009–2011)

33% wins 6 played, 2 wins, 4 losses

Grade	Round Rd	Date	Home	Away	Score
2011
C18	Grand FinalGF	(Sun) Aug 21	Old CareyOld Carey	NOBSPCNOBS	102 – 38 102 – 38	L
C18	Round 1515	Jul 30	NOBSPCNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	53 – 78 53 – 78	L
C18	Round 88	Jun 4	Old CareyOld Carey	NOBSPCNOBS	153 – 43 153 – 43	L
2010
C18	Round 1313	Jul 17	Old CareyOld Carey	NOBSPCNOBS	62 – 90 62 – 90	W
C18	Round 99	Jun 19	NOBSPCNOBS	Old CareyOld Carey	111 – 68 111 – 68	W
2009
C18	Round 1111	Jul 4	Old CareyOld Carey	NOBSPCNOBS	127 – 65 127 – 65	L